May 2026
The Backwards Law: Why Trying Harder Doesn't Always Get Us What We Want
Maybe that's why an idea from Alan Watts has followed me around for years. In his book The Wisdom of Insecurity, he explores what he calls the law of reversed effort, or the backwards law. It's the idea that our efforts to secure certain experiences can sometimes interfere with having them. The harder we try to feel confident, the more conscious we become of our insecurities. We want to be happy, so we keep checking whether we are. Before long, we're paying more attention to what's missing than to what's happening.

The other day I was standing in my kitchen waiting for water to boil. It wasn't taking an unusual amount of time. The stove was working and the pot was doing exactly what pots do. But every few seconds I found myself glancing over at it as if my attention might somehow speed up the process. I laughed when I noticed it because I've done the same thing with elevators, browser tabs, text messages, and just about every uncertain period of my life. For someone who claims to understand that things take time, I spend a surprising amount of energy trying to negotiate with reality.
Maybe that's why an idea from Alan Watts has followed me around for years. In his book The Wisdom of Insecurity, he explores what he calls the law of reversed effort, or the backwards law. It's the idea that our efforts to secure certain experiences can sometimes interfere with having them. The harder we try to feel confident, the more conscious we become of our insecurities. We want to be happy, so we keep checking whether we are. Before long, we're paying more attention to what's missing than to what's happening.
When I first encountered the idea, I thought it was an interesting philosophical observation. It seemed clever in the way certain ideas do when you're reading them from a comfortable distance. Over time, though, I began noticing how often it appeared in ordinary life, particularly in situations where I cared a great deal about the outcome.
Confidence is probably the clearest example for me. For a long time, I treated it as something I needed to acquire before I could fully participate in my own life. Before speaking up or putting my work into the world, I wanted reassurance that I wouldn't embarrass myself. I was waiting to become someone who could do those things without feeling uncertain, which turns out to be an excellent way to spend a lot of time waiting.
The strange thing is that the periods when I've felt most comfortable with myself weren't usually the ones when I was thinking about confidence at all. I was learning something new, working on a project that interested me, or enjoying a conversation without wondering how I came across. My attention was on what I was doing rather than on whether I was doing it confidently enough.
There's also something slightly ridiculous about expecting ourselves to feel completely comfortable doing things we've never done before. We want the reassurance of experience without going through the awkward business of acquiring it. Sometimes we have to participate while still feeling unsure, and the familiarity comes later. Even then, I don't think confidence means never doubting ourselves. It may simply mean that doubt isn't always the deciding factor.
Happiness has been a little trickier for me because it's so easy to attach it to something tangible. For a long time, I imagined a future version of myself who had everything a little more figured out. She seemed calmer and more settled, and I assumed she'd arrive once I'd accomplished whatever goal was occupying my attention at the time.
Except the finish line had a habit of moving. I'd achieve something I'd spent months working toward, enjoy the satisfaction for a while, and then gradually become accustomed to it. The new job became my regular job. The apartment I'd been so excited about became the place where I did laundry and wondered what to make for dinner. None of that made the accomplishment meaningless. It was just strange how quickly something I'd imagined would change the way I felt could become an ordinary part of my life.
I started wondering whether I was asking too much of those milestones. A promotion can change your responsibilities or financial circumstances, but it can't necessarily settle every insecurity you have about your career. Moving somewhere new can be exciting without making every day exciting. Accomplishments have value on their own, even when they don't deliver the permanent feeling we imagined would come with them.
Sleep might be the funniest example of the backwards law because almost everyone has experienced it. You can do all the sensible things to prepare for bed, but once you start demanding that your body fall asleep immediately, the whole situation tends to become more complicated. Suddenly you're staring at the clock, calculating how many hours remain before the alarm goes off, and becoming increasingly irritated that you're still awake. It's remarkable how quickly trying to relax can turn into another thing to worry about.
What makes these situations interesting to me is that they aren't really about a lack of effort. You can practice a skill, pursue a promotion, or create better conditions for sleep. Those things may help. But there's a point where the practical work ends and we begin trying to control something that doesn't respond particularly well to being managed.
I've noticed the difference in smaller moments, too. Some of my favorite memories involve sitting on a porch while a conversation wandered nowhere in particular or drinking coffee before anyone else was awake. There was nothing I was trying to accomplish, and I wasn't thinking about whether I was making good use of my time. I was simply enjoying what was happening. Looking back, I doubt those moments would have felt quite the same if I'd been monitoring how happy they were making me.
Of course, I don't think the answer is to stop caring about things or abandon our ambitions. Some goals require sustained effort, and there are plenty of situations where doing more really does improve the outcome. If you're learning a language, studying matters. If you're trying to repair a relationship, difficult conversations may be necessary. The backwards law isn't an excuse to avoid the uncomfortable parts of pursuing something important.
Where I find it useful is in recognizing the difference between doing what I can and insisting on a particular result. I can prepare for a conversation, but I can't guarantee that the other person will understand me. I can put care into something I create, but I can't decide how everyone will respond to it. And I can work toward a goal without knowing in advance whether achieving it will feel the way I expect.
That last part is harder than it sounds. It's easy to appreciate an idea about accepting uncertainty when nothing particularly important is at stake. It's considerably more difficult when you're waiting for an answer or wondering whether something you've worked toward will turn out as you'd hoped. Understanding the limits of your control doesn't make you immune to wanting more of it.
I still catch myself checking the pot to see if the water is boiling yet. Despite knowing perfectly well that staring at it won't make anything happen faster, I occasionally find myself doing it anyway. Apparently, understanding the backwards law hasn't made me any better at waiting for water to boil.
Keep reading
The archive

