November 2026
How an Aruba ATV Excursion Cost Me a Fingernail Before My Birthday
The day before my birthday, I was riding an ATV through Aruba with my hair blowing in the wind, having the time of my life. My best friend was with me, the weather was beautiful, and I was feeling pretty good about my decision to spend the afternoon exploring the island. Little did I know that a few hours later, I'd be sitting in a hospital waiting room, covered in dirt, wondering what was going to happen to my fingernail.
Filed from
Noord, Aruba

The day before my birthday, I was riding an ATV through Aruba with my hair blowing in the wind, having the time of my life. My best friend was with me, the weather was beautiful, and I was feeling pretty good about my decision to spend the afternoon exploring the island. Little did I know that a few hours later, I'd be sitting in a hospital waiting room, covered in dirt, wondering what was going to happen to my fingernail.
Things took a turn when my ATV suddenly stalled so hard that I nearly went off a cliff. I reacted as quickly as I could, jerking the ATV away from the edge, and somehow my right ring fingernail bent all the way backward. At first, I thought I'd just peeled back my gel polish. But when I saw blood going everywhere, I realized it wasn't the gel. It was my actual fingernail.
The problem was, we were in the middle of nowhere, halfway through the ATV excursion. The guides cleaned my finger as best they could and gave me a blue glove to wear for the rest of the ride. I swear I looked like Michael Jackson, except my glove was blue and considerably less glamorous. I had a throbbing finger, dirt all over me, and the rest of an ATV excursion to finish.
So I did what any reasonable person who's already committed to an excursion apparently does. I smiled through the pain and kept going. Thankfully, my best friend was there with me and was incredibly supportive throughout the ordeal. Considering I'd nearly gone over a cliff, I figured I was pretty lucky to be worrying about a fingernail.

Once the excursion ended, I went straight to the hospital. I was hurting too much to stop at the Airbnb and shower, so I brought what felt like half of Aruba's dirt along with me. At the time, my appearance was the least of my concerns. That would become a problem later.
Several guides on our earlier excursions had warned us about the pace of life in Aruba. Things move slowly on the island, they'd said. Really slowly. I'd heard them, but apparently I hadn't considered that this might become relevant to me. I was about to find out exactly what they meant.
When we first arrived at Dr. Horacio E. Oduber Hospital, I assumed I'd be seen fairly quickly. Maybe that's the American in me, but I thought showing up with a fingernail bent backward into my finger would at least get things moving. Instead, the woman at the main desk told me I'd be waiting at least three hours and that treatment would cost more than $500. That was the minimum. And to make things even better, they didn't accept medical insurance, even if I'd purchased travel insurance. At that point, I was thinking, yeah, no. Surely we could find another option.
Thankfully, we'd already looked up urgent-care facilities on the island, just in case we needed one. So rather than commit to a three-hour wait and a bill of more than $500, I decided we should try one of those instead. We got there around 5 p.m., only to discover it was already closed. Wonderful. We'd managed to take a little tour of Aruba's medical facilities, and I still had the same injured fingernail. With that option off the table, we headed back to the hospital, where I paid the $100 deposit and settled in for what turned out to be a much longer wait than I'd originally been warned about.
During my initial assessment, I was told that the nail would have to be pushed back into place rather than removed. That sounded absolutely awful, especially considering how much pain I was already in. I asked whether I could just rip the thing off myself and be done with it. I was told no, that wasn't an option, and I'd have to wait for a doctor to put it back.
Fine. I trusted what they were telling me, even though I wasn't particularly looking forward to having someone push my nail back into my finger. What I hadn't anticipated was how long I'd have to sit there thinking about it.
As the hours passed, I learned more about how the emergency department worked. I was told that patients arriving by ambulance could be seen ahead of others depending on the seriousness of their condition, which made perfect sense. Someone experiencing a life-threatening emergency should absolutely receive treatment before a woman who'd managed to destroy one fingernail on vacation. I understood that, but after sitting there for hours in pain, I wasn't exactly feeling my most patient.
By the time I was finally called into the treatment area, six hours had passed. Six hours in a hospital waiting room, the day before my birthday, when I could have been at the beach, having dinner, or doing just about anything else. Instead, I was about to discover that the information I'd been given when I arrived wasn't even correct.
The doctor examined my finger and explained that pushing the nail back into place wasn't an option after all. The entire thing needed to be removed. I really wish you could have seen my face when he told me that. I'd spent six hours waiting because I'd been told the nail had to be saved, and now the doctor was recommending exactly what I'd asked about when I first arrived. Between the pain, exhaustion, and realization that I'd lost most of the day before my birthday, I finally lost my cool a little.
But something surprisingly good came out of that frustration. Because I'd been given incorrect information about the treatment, the doctor went straight to the front desk and told the staff I wouldn't be charged anything beyond the $100 deposit I'd already paid. Considering the much larger bill I'd been warned about, I was relieved. I certainly wouldn't have chosen to spend six hours in the hospital to save money, but I wasn't about to argue with the one piece of good financial news I'd received all afternoon.

The doctor numbed my finger, picked up a rather intimidating pair of surgical scissors, and removed the nail. And can we talk about how ugly fingers look without fingernails? I had never really considered how much a fingernail contributes to a finger's appearance until I was staring at mine without one. It looked completely ridiculous. I was already annoyed about losing the nail, but now I was also offended by how ugly my finger was. Apparently, having nine perfectly normal fingernails and one naked finger is enough to make your entire hand look suspicious. And in case you're wondering, the photo to the right is what my fingernail looks like as of November 16, 2026. We're making progress, although I wouldn't exactly call it manicure ready.
While treating me, the doctor also told me about tourists who'd suffered much more serious injuries during ATV excursions, including people who'd lost legs. Hearing that after my own ATV had nearly gone over a cliff was unsettling. Suddenly, losing a fingernail didn't seem quite so terrible. I was more than willing to keep my leg and sacrifice a nail.
After cleaning and bandaging my finger, the doctor gave me extra supplies so I wouldn't have to buy everything afterward. He also managed to find something funny about the situation. "At least you'll get a discount on your manicures for the next six months," he joked. I couldn't help laughing at the idea that my one consolation was having only nine nails to paint instead of ten. It wasn't exactly the birthday gift I'd been hoping for, but I appreciated his sense of humor.
Just when I thought the most embarrassing part of the day was over, I stood up from the hospital bed and looked behind me. You know those outlines of bodies you see in crime shows? Imagine something similar, except instead of chalk, it was made entirely of dirt. I'd left a full outline of my body on the bed. I knew I'd arrived dirty, obviously, but I hadn't realized I was dirty enough to leave behind what looked like evidence from a crime scene.
I was mortified. I kept apologizing to the medical staff and explaining that this wasn't what I normally looked like, which probably made the whole thing even more ridiculous. I'm not entirely sure why I felt the need to reassure everyone that I generally practice basic hygiene, but apparently that was important to me at the time.
Before leaving, the nurse handed me my discharge paperwork, which explained how to care for my finger while the nail grew back. There was just one problem: everything was in Dutch. When I asked about it, she explained that the hospital's system only gave her the option to print the instructions in Dutch. So after six hours in the hospital, I had the additional pleasure of translating my own medical paperwork to figure out how to care for my finger over the coming months. I left with my bandages, extra supplies, and instructions I couldn't read without a little help from technology.
By the time I finally got back to the Airbnb, all I wanted was a shower and my bed. I took what might have been the longest shower of my life, determined to wash off every last bit of Aruba I'd apparently brought home with me. Once I was finally clean, I was more than ready to call it a night.

The next day was my birthday, and my best friend made sure it was a special one. She took me to an amazing restaurant right on the water, where we watched one of the most beautiful sunsets I'd ever seen. As I sat there looking out at the ocean, I thought about how Aruba is known as “One Happy Island.” After everything that had happened, I couldn't help but smile. It really is hard to stay mad in a place like that.
Keep reading
The archive

